Florida's Insurance Rate Changes Expected to Be Among the Nation's Lowest in 2025

Florida's Insurance Rate Changes Expected to Be Among the Nation's Lowest in 2025
 
There's good news in Florida. For years, homeowners across the country have faced significantly increasing homeowners’ insurance premiums, making affordability a major issue in the U.S., and Florida has been no exception. While storms, rising property values, and inflation have certainly played a role, the real culprit was something far less obvious to those of us paying the premiums: a legal system that had been heavily exploited, leading to an overwhelming number of frivolous lawsuits artificially driving up costs for homeowners.

To put this issue into perspective, in 2021, Florida accounted for just 6.9% of all property insurance claims in the U.S., yet it made up over a staggering 76% of all property insurance lawsuits in the entire country. That kind of legal environment isn’t just a headache for insurance companies, it drives up costs for everyone. The only winners are the lawyers on the billboards. Insurers, facing unpredictable legal expenses, have to pass that “cost of doing business” onto homeowners, leading to artificially higher insurance premiums.

To highlight the importance of addressing Florida’s lawsuit abuse crisis for long-term economic prosperity and competitiveness, the Florida Chamber Foundation’s Florida 2030 Blueprint established a goal to unite Florida's business community in targeted efforts to improve Florida’s legal climate to top 12 in the U.S. by 2030 (up from bottom-five on the most recent ranking).

Here’s the good news: things are starting to turn around. Thanks to key Florida Chamber-backed legislative reforms in 2022 and 2023 that Governor DeSantis and legislative leaders made a priority, Florida is seeing a shift in the market that’s bringing in new insurers and leading to rate reductions, rate freezes and slower premium increases for others. And compared to what’s happening in the rest of the country, Florida’s progress is even more impressive.


What Changed? The Impact of Florida’s Legal Reforms

Recognizing the urgency of the problem, the Florida business community united behind an effort to advocate for change. As a result, Florida lawmakers passed Senate Bill 2-A (SB 2-A) in December 2022 and House Bill 837 (HB 837) in March 2023. These laws were designed to tackle the core issues driving up insurance costs.

Key Findings:
  • Reducing frivolous lawsuits: Championing consumers by tightening rules around attorney fees and bad-faith claims, these reforms made it less attractive for predatory law firms to file excessive lawsuits against insurers.
  • Encouraging more competition: The new legal landscape created a more stable environment for insurers, leading to 11 new companies entering the Florida property insurance market since the reforms were signed into law by Governor DeSantis.
  • Curbing fraud and abuse: The reforms also introduced measures to prevent practices that were inflating claims, leading to unnecessary claim disputes that were clogging the system and driving up costs for homeowners.
The impact has been significant. Since January 2024, 17 companies have filed for a rate decrease and 34 companies have requested no rate increase. According to Florida’s Office of Insurance Regulation, about 3.4 million homeowners will see either a rate decrease or no increase at all when they renew their policies, something almost unheard of in recent years.

A Different Story Across the Country
While Florida is finally seeing some stability, other states are heading in the opposite direction. Across the U.S., home insurance premiums have jumped by double digits for the second year in a row, largely due to rising natural disaster risks, lawsuit abuse, and inflation. In 2024, Nebraska saw the largest calculated increase in premiums at 22.7%, with five other states also seeing an increase of more than 20%: Montana, Iowa, Minnesota, Utah, and Washington—over the one-year period.
 
 
Looking back further, other states like Louisiana, California, and Texas have been experiencing severe insurance crises since 2019, with major carriers pulling out of high-risk areas and homeowners struggling to find affordable coverage.
  • In Louisiana, insurers have been leaving the market, forcing the state-run insurer of last resort (Louisiana Citizens) to take on more policies—driving up rates even further.
  • California is seeing a similar trend, as national insurers like State Farm and Allstate have stopped writing new policies in parts of the state.
  • In Texas, increased storm activity and inflation have led to some of the steepest rate hikes in the nation. Since 2019, their rates have increased 54.5%.
By contrast, Florida’s reforms have attracted new insurers instead of scaring them away. The increase in competition and reduction in litigation costs are a big reason why Florida’s premium hikes have stabilized, and our rate changes are expected to be some of the lowest in the country in 2025.

What’s Next?

While Florida’s property insurance rates aren’t dropping across the board just yet, they are stabilizing, which is a major win for homeowners. The biggest takeaway is that the reforms are working. By addressing the legal system issues that were driving up costs, Florida has created an environment where insurers want to do business.

As more insurers enter the market and competition increases, we can expect the pressure on rates to ease even further. While homeowners in other states brace for even steeper hikes, Florida is proving that bold reform can make a real difference.

So, if you’ve been dreading your next insurance renewal, there’s finally some good news—you might not see much of a rate hike, if at all. And for many Floridians, that’s a welcome change.

.